# Eddy Keming Chen Cuts His Superintelligence Forecast to One Year After OpenAI's Navier-Stokes Proof

> Eddy Keming Chen of UC San Diego put superintelligence perhaps within a year on Sept. 28, citing OpenAI's Lean-checked Navier-Stokes proof; Gary Marcus calls the AGI claim a redefinition, and capability moves up 0.4.

- Published: 2026-09-28
- Author: Ryan Elliott Dennis
- Company: OpenAI
- Canonical: https://si-infra.com/journal/openai-navier-stokes-within-a-year
- Ledger move: +0.4 Capability (reported). Reading after Sept. 28, 2026: 0.7% of the way to superintelligence on the public record.

Eddy Keming Chen, a philosopher at UC San Diego, said on Sept. 28 that superintelligence may arrive within a year [1]. His main exhibit is OpenAI's 166-page proof about fluid flow, which Lean software has checked and mathematicians are still untangling [8].

Chen, an associate professor with a joint appointment in philosophy and the Halıcıoğlu Data Science Institute, answered UC San Diego Today's one question [1]. "When we wrote our Nature Comment in Feb. 2026, I thought superintelligence might still be five years away," Chen said. "Recent developments have changed my assessment. I now believe we may reach this reality sooner than anticipated, perhaps even within a year". His example is OpenAI's claim that an internal system of AI agents produced a proposed solution to the Navier-Stokes Millennium Prize Problem, with a formalization in Lean, software that checks proofs step by step[5].

Three grades of evidence sit in that answer: a proof under review, its machine check and a revised forecast. Proof and check earn a small step up in capability, 0.4 points at reported confidence. His forecast stays off the scale, since the reading counts evidence and a forecast is a judgment about it. Chen wants the aims chosen now: "Faster scientific discovery and new medical treatments could bring enormous benefits for humanity. But there is disagreement about which goals to pursue and for whose benefit. Achieving superintelligence alone does not resolve those disagreements" [1].

## What did OpenAI's agents produce?

OpenAI's 166-page paper, posted Sept. 8, describes a fluid that "starts from rest and develops unbounded velocity in finite time while maintaining uniformly bounded kinetic energy" [5]. Put plainly: a still fluid, stirred by a smooth force, spins up until its speed at one point runs to infinity. For air, George Karniadakis of Brown University told Nature that "the singularity appears when [the] vortex becomes around 70 nanometres wide," the Tufts Daily reported [14]. At that width air is a crowd of molecules, and the equations have stopped describing it.

The run took under four days. OpenAI's announcement, quoted by Simon Willison, set the clock: "The agents arrived at their resolution on Saturday, September 5, about 88 hours after the first agents were launched" [6]. About 10,000 agents sent 2.7 million messages and used about 130 billion output tokens, and GPT-6 Astra, a public model, spent 17 hours on the Lean version[7]. NPR put the compute at roughly $6 million to $10 million at OpenAI's public prices [8].

Human mathematicians built the method. Quanta Magazine's Konstantin Kakaes reported that the OpenAI team and two mathematicians, Tristan Buckmaster of New York University and Levent Alpöge of Anthropic, "relied heavily on work by Diego Córdoba of the Institute for Mathematical Sciences in Madrid and Luis Martínez-Zoroa of CUNEF University" [7]. OpenAI started on Sept. 1 after a rumor it later tied to the pair, who had used Claude and OpenAI's Codex on the problem for most of a year [6].

## What did Lean check, and what must mathematicians still check?

A Lean check proves one thing: that the argument establishes the statement written in Lean. OpenAI's repository says its files establish Clay's alternatives (C) and (D), breakdown in all of space and on a periodic box, and credits Google DeepMind's Formal Conjectures project for the Lean statement of the problem it adapted [11]. Lean checked the proof against a question that began as Google DeepMind's text.

Mathematicians still have to confirm that the Lean question matches the problem Clay posed in 2000. Kakaes spelled it out: "The crucial bit of verification that must still be done by humans is to guarantee that the statement being shown to be true in Lean is logically equivalent to what mathematicians set out to prove" [7]. Charles Fefferman's official statement lets alternative (C) use a smooth external force, and OpenAI's result uses one [5][14]. Tapio Schneider, in a guest post on Terence Tao's blog, marked the rest: "The unforced version of the problem, whether smooth solutions exist for all time without external forcing, remains open" [13].

Javier Gómez-Serrano of Brown University told NPR the Lean code compiled and "the community seems to have the consensus that it is correct" [8]. On Sept. 11 the Clay Mathematics Institute wrote that "the Navier-Stokes problem has apparently been settled," adding that its process "is deliberately unhurried" [9]. Its rules require publication in a qualifying outlet, two years of waiting and general acceptance before Clay will consider a solution [10]. Formalizing and checking the proof in Lean took 17 hours. A checker certifies a proof in hours; a field certifies a problem in years.

## Is AGI already here?

UC San Diego Today framed superintelligence as a onetime science-fiction premise that researchers now debate in earnest, with little agreement on whether or when it arrives [1]. Chen's forecast rests on an earlier claim. "Superintelligence is greater than general intelligence," he said, and general intelligence, he holds, has arrived. He argued it in a Nature Comment published Feb. 2 with three UC San Diego colleagues, Mikhail Belkin, Leon Bergen and David Danks, whose fields run from data and computer science to linguistics, cognitive science and policy [2][3]. Danks now teaches at the University of Virginia[19]. "We are at a Copernican moment where we are questioning the very notion of whether general intelligence is uniquely human," Chen said. Belkin used the same frame in February: "Copernicus displaced humans from the center of the universe, Darwin displaced humans from a privileged place in nature; now we are contending with the prospect that there are more kinds of minds than we had previously entertained".

Chen sets the bar for superintelligence high: AI that would "exceed the abilities of leading human experts across almost all areas of thought," at a level past what humans could reach "individually or collectively" [1]. "Insofar as individual humans have general intelligence, a frontier AI has that too," Chen said, but "our argument for artificial general intelligence (AGI) does not establish the arrival of superintelligence".

Gary Marcus, the NYU professor emeritus, answered in Nature on Feb. 17 with Walter Quattrociocchi of Sapienza University of Rome and Valerio Capraro of the University of Milan-Bicocca [4]. "Such claims confuse high performance on benchmarks (often gameable) with real world flexibility, which historically has been at the center of what it means to be an artificial general intelligence," Marcus wrote. Their longer essay anticipated this month's exhibit: "Reports that language models have produced correct proofs for isolated open problems in mathematics, including specific Erdős problems, do not alter this assessment".

What does the objection change? The Lean check stands, since a compiled proof is a fact about one theorem. Marcus targets the leap from one theorem to general intelligence, and there he and Chen sit closer than their headlines suggest. Chen's own sentence names the missing test: "establishing superintelligence across almost all areas would require much broader evaluation" [1]. Both men want a measurement across many environments, and that measurement has yet to happen.

## Why the step stays small

Three facts hold it down: an internal model, a disputed path and a narrow base.

Start with the model. OpenAI says the system behind the proof began training on Aug. 28, and it stays in-house [15][7]. The capability component asks about public systems.

Then the path, on which a Lean file is silent. OpenAI's own announcement conceded: "While unlikely, we cannot rule out that de-identified data derived from their usage of our products helped improve our models" [6]. A test counts as uncontaminated when the answer's path stays clear of the test-taker's inputs, and OpenAI itself leaves that open.

Last, the base. OpenAI says the same model solved more than 100 long-standing problems in a month of training, and The Decoder noted that which problems it solved, and how, remain open questions [15]. James Maynard, a Fields medallist at the University of Oxford, named the cost to the field: "So far it's been very difficult to really extract any human understanding from this new AI proof" [8]. On Sept. 11 he and 24 other Fields Medal winners, Terence Tao among them, called the goals of AI companies and of mathematicians "severely misaligned" [12]. Manlio De Domenico of the Complexity Thoughts newsletter put it plainly: "It has not yet become an officially recognized solution under Clay's process" [21].

Where does that leave the reading? Capability moves up 0.4, reported. Reported, because the claim rests on OpenAI's paper and announcement, carried by the press of record and backed by an outside compile of the Lean files; confirmed needs a public system and a clean provenance. This ledger moved capability 0.6 for Anthropic's [Fermat formalization](/journal/anthropic-fermat-eleven-days) on Sept. 4 and 0.6 when [FrontierMath Tier 4](/journal/openai-frontiermath-tier-4) fell on Sept. 10. Navier-Stokes has more depth than either: new mathematics on an open problem of the first rank, the test the Fermat piece named. It has less provenance. Fermat also came from an internal model, but it restated a public human proof and Kevin Buzzard put his name to the check; FrontierMath fell to a public model. This result has a disputed path and a Lean statement awaiting a named check. Chen's forecast adds 0.0.

## Who keeps the ability to change course?

Chen asks whether the ability to evaluate and guide AI can keep pace with its capabilities. Leading AI companies, he noted, say their researchers increasingly use AI agents to run experiments and train future AIs [1]. "If we delegate more of the development of future AI to systems whose reasoning we do not fully understand, how do we retain the ability to assess the results and, when appropriate, change course?" Chen asked. The Decoder reported on Sept. 27 that Anthropic puts the human share of research-direction decisions in single digits, and that OpenAI runs GPT-5.6 Sol across its development cycle; a study it covered, from a team building its own model, found people made the final call on goals in 93.4 percent of cases [16].

OpenAI answered the mathematicians with an independent advisory group and one stated limit. "Importantly, the group will not be responsible for advising us on how to pace our internal progress on mathematics," the company wrote [8]. OpenAI, which supplied Chen's exhibit, kept the pace for itself.

His remedy is access, with universities pairing technical research with philosophy and the social and data sciences, and giving researchers room to scrutinize developers' claims [1]. "We especially need independent and rigorous evaluations of what the most capable AI systems can do and whether their safeguards still work," Chen said. "That requires access to the systems and the freedom to publish critical findings". He also sets aside a human ceiling: "There is no reason to assume that human intelligence represents a fundamental ceiling for artificial systems".

UC San Diego takes up the argument in October. Ted Chiang, whose "Story of Your Life" became the Academy Award-nominated film "Arrival," gives a free lecture at the Halıcıoğlu Data Science Institute on Oct. 16, in a series honoring the late author and San Diego State professor Vernor Vinge [1][17]. Its title disputes a premise of Chen's Nature Comment: "No Machine Has Passed the Turing Test". On Oct. 17, Chiang and Kim Stanley Robinson, a UC San Diego alumnus, hold a free conversation and a 10th-anniversary screening of "Arrival" at the Epstein Family Amphitheater, presented by ArtPower[18]. Chen closed with the last sentence of Alan Turing's 1950 paper: "We can only see a short distance ahead, but we can see plenty there that needs to be done"[20].

## By the numbers

- 166 pages in OpenAI's Navier-Stokes paper, posted Sept. 8 [5]
- Roughly 10,000 agents for about 88 hours, then 17 hours of Lean work by GPT-6 Astra [6][7]
- About 130 billion output tokens on Navier-Stokes, out of 300 billion across every problem attempted [6]
- $6 million to $10 million: NPR's estimate of the Navier-Stokes compute at public prices [8]
- Two years at minimum between publication and Clay's consideration of a solution [10]

## What to watch

Clay's review is the slow, decisive marker: peer-reviewed publication and general acceptance would lift this step toward the confirmed band. Sooner, named mathematicians checking the Lean statement against Fefferman's text would settle the fit question. OpenAI publishing its 100-plus problems, misses included, would test breadth, which Chen and Marcus both ask for. The open question that decides the next move is Chen's own: whether outside researchers get access to these systems, and the freedom to publish what they find, before the next result arrives.

## Sources

1. Johnson, Erika. "How Close Are We to Artificial Superintelligence?" UC San Diego Today, Sept. 28, 2026. https://today.ucsd.edu/story/how-close-are-we-to-artificial-superintelligence
2. Chen, Eddy Keming, Mikhail Belkin, Leon Bergen and David Danks. "Does AI already have human-level intelligence? The evidence is clear." Nature 650, 36-40, Feb. 2, 2026. https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-026-00285-6
3. Johnson, Erika. "Is Artificial General Intelligence Here?" UC San Diego Today, Feb. 2, 2026. https://today.ucsd.edu/story/is-artificial-general-intelligence-here
4. Marcus, Gary, Walter Quattrociocchi and Valerio Capraro. "Rumors of AGI's arrival have been greatly exaggerated." Marcus on AI, Feb. 17, 2026. https://garymarcus.substack.com/p/rumors-of-agis-arrival-have-been
5. OpenAI. "Finite Time Blowup for Navier–Stokes." OpenAI, Sept. 8, 2026. https://cdn.openai.com/pdf/32d9f210-8b73-45e0-91bc-82a30aef8a9a/navier-stokes.pdf
6. Willison, Simon. "Some thoughts on the Navier–Stokes Millennium Prize Problem." Simon Willison's Weblog, Sept. 8, 2026. https://simonwillison.net/2026/Sep/8/on-navier-stokes/
7. Kakaes, Konstantin. "AI Has Solved One of Math's $1 Million Millennium Prize Problems." Quanta Magazine, Sept. 8, 2026. https://www.quantamagazine.org/ai-has-solved-one-of-maths-1-million-millennium-prize-problems-20260908/
8. Brumfiel, Geoff. "AI solved one of math's hardest problems. Humanity learned nothing (so far)." NPR, Sept. 22, 2026. https://www.npr.org/2026/09/22/nx-s1-5968588/openai-navier-stokes-problem-mathematicians-learn-little
9. Clay Mathematics Institute. "Navier-Stokes Announcement." Clay Mathematics Institute, Sept. 11, 2026. https://www.claymath.org/news/navier-stokes-announcement/
10. Clay Mathematics Institute. "Rules for the Millennium Prize Problems." Clay Mathematics Institute, adopted Sept. 26, 2018. https://www.claymath.org/millennium-problems/rules/
11. OpenAI. "Finite time blowup for Navier–Stokes and Euler equations." NavierStokesAndEuler repository README, GitHub, Sept. 8, 2026. https://github.com/openai/NavierStokesAndEuler
12. Tao, Terence, and 24 other Fields Medallists. "A Severe Misalignment of AI in Mathematics." What's new, Sept. 11, 2026. https://terrytao.wordpress.com/2026/09/11/a-severe-misalignment-of-ai-in-mathematics/
13. Schneider, Tapio. "Headlines and inside stories: understanding and trust in AI for mathematics, science, and engineering." What's new (guest post), Sept. 23, 2026. https://terrytao.wordpress.com/2026/09/23/headlines-and-inside-stories-understanding-and-trust-in-ai-for-mathematics-science-and-engineering/
14. Kavas, Hande Naz. "Mathematicians still checking the Navier-Stokes proof that OpenAI claims to have solved." The Tufts Daily, Sept. 24, 2026. https://www.tuftsdaily.com/article/2026/09/mathematicians-still-checking-the-navier-stokes-proof-that-openai-claims-to-have-solved
15. Bastian, Matthias. "OpenAI says its internal model solved over 100 long-standing math problems after just a month of training." The Decoder, Sept. 22, 2026. https://the-decoder.com/openai-says-its-internal-model-solved-over-100-long-standing-math-problems-after-just-a-month-of-training/
16. Kemper, Jonathan. "AI agents do more of the work in model development, but humans still make the decisions." The Decoder, Sept. 27, 2026. https://the-decoder.com/ai-agents-do-more-of-the-work-in-model-development-but-humans-still-make-the-decisions/
17. TILOS. "Vernor Vinge Lecture Series on the Future of AI and Society with Ted Chiang: No Machine Has Passed the Turing Test." Event listing, Oct. 16, 2026. https://tilos.ai/event/vv-lecture-series-with-ted-chiang-no-machine-has-passed-the-turing-test/
18. ArtPower at UC San Diego. "Arrival Film Screening and Conversation." Epstein Family Amphitheater, Oct. 17, 2026. https://amphitheater.ucsd.edu/event/arrival/
19. University of Virginia School of Data Science. "David Danks." Faculty page, 2026. https://datascience.virginia.edu/people/david-danks
20. Turing, A. M. "Computing Machinery and Intelligence." Mind 59, 433-460, October 1950. https://www.hec.edu/sites/default/files/documents/Computing%20Machinery%20and%20Intelligence%20by%20Alan%20Turing.pdf
21. De Domenico, Manlio. "No, AI hasn't officially solved Navier–Stokes. Yet." Complexity Thoughts, Sept. 10, 2026. https://manlius.substack.com/p/no-ai-hasnt-officially-solved-navierstokes

## Images

- ![The angular concrete and glass Geisel Library at UC San Diego, wide at the top and narrow at its base](https://si-infra.com/img/openai-navier-stokes-within-a-year/1.jpg) Geisel Library at UC San Diego, photographed Sept. 23, 2020. Philosopher Eddy Keming Chen gave his one-year superintelligence forecast to the university's news office on Sept. 28. (Photo: Westxtk, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:UC_San_Diego_Geisel_Library.jpg)
- ![Red smoke curling into a large spiral vortex behind a small crop-dusting plane flying low over a field](https://si-infra.com/img/openai-navier-stokes-within-a-year/2.jpg) Coloured smoke traces the wingtip vortex behind an agricultural plane in a NASA wake study at Wallops Island on May 4, 1990. (Photo: NASA Langley Research Center (NASA-LaRC), Edited by Fir0002, Wikimedia Commons, Public domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Airplane_vortex_edit.jpg)
- ![Three fluid-flow equations in white mathematical notation on a dark red background](https://si-infra.com/img/openai-navier-stokes-within-a-year/3.jpg) The Navier-Stokes equations in the compressible form printed in Sander Bais's 2005 book. Clay's Millennium problem asks about their incompressible form in three dimensions. (Photo: Sander Bais. Gijs Mathijs Ontwerpers, Amsterdam, Wikimedia Commons, Public domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Navier-Stokes_equations.jpg)
- ![Glass entrance of the Andrew Wiles Building at Oxford behind a courtyard paved in a Penrose tiling](https://si-infra.com/img/openai-navier-stokes-within-a-year/4.jpg) The Andrew Wiles Building, home of Oxford's Mathematical Institute, in October 2013. Fields medallist James Maynard of Oxford said human understanding is hard to extract from the AI proof. (Photo: Alain Goriely, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:The_Mathematical_Institute_at_Oxford_University.jpg)
- ![Slate sculpture of Alan Turing seated at a desk working at a machine, in a museum gallery](https://si-infra.com/img/openai-navier-stokes-within-a-year/5.jpg) Stephen Kettle's 2007 slate statue of Alan Turing in the Bletchley Park Block B museum, photographed March 12, 2016. Chen closed with the last sentence of Turing's 1950 paper. (Photo: DeFacto, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Alan_Turing_by_Stephen_Kettle_2007.jpg)

## Sources

1. How Close Are We to Artificial Superintelligence? (UC San Diego Today, 2026-09-28) https://today.ucsd.edu/story/how-close-are-we-to-artificial-superintelligence
2. Does AI already have human-level intelligence? The evidence is clear (Nature, 2026-02-02) https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-026-00285-6
3. Is Artificial General Intelligence Here? (UC San Diego Today, 2026-02-02) https://today.ucsd.edu/story/is-artificial-general-intelligence-here
4. Rumors of AGI's arrival have been greatly exaggerated (Marcus on AI, 2026-02-17) https://garymarcus.substack.com/p/rumors-of-agis-arrival-have-been
5. Finite Time Blowup for Navier–Stokes (OpenAI, 2026-09-08) https://cdn.openai.com/pdf/32d9f210-8b73-45e0-91bc-82a30aef8a9a/navier-stokes.pdf
6. Some thoughts on the Navier–Stokes Millennium Prize Problem (Simon Willison's Weblog, 2026-09-08) https://simonwillison.net/2026/Sep/8/on-navier-stokes/
7. AI Has Solved One of Math's $1 Million Millennium Prize Problems (Quanta Magazine, 2026-09-08) https://www.quantamagazine.org/ai-has-solved-one-of-maths-1-million-millennium-prize-problems-20260908/
8. AI solved one of math's hardest problems. Humanity learned nothing (so far) (NPR, 2026-09-22) https://www.npr.org/2026/09/22/nx-s1-5968588/openai-navier-stokes-problem-mathematicians-learn-little
9. Navier-Stokes Announcement (Clay Mathematics Institute, 2026-09-11) https://www.claymath.org/news/navier-stokes-announcement/
10. Rules for the Millennium Prize Problems (Clay Mathematics Institute, 2018-09-26) https://www.claymath.org/millennium-problems/rules/
11. Finite time blowup for Navier–Stokes and Euler equations (OpenAI (GitHub), 2026-09-08) https://github.com/openai/NavierStokesAndEuler
12. A Severe Misalignment of AI in Mathematics (What's new (Terence Tao), 2026-09-11) https://terrytao.wordpress.com/2026/09/11/a-severe-misalignment-of-ai-in-mathematics/
13. Headlines and inside stories: understanding and trust in AI for mathematics, science, and engineering (What's new (Terence Tao), 2026-09-23) https://terrytao.wordpress.com/2026/09/23/headlines-and-inside-stories-understanding-and-trust-in-ai-for-mathematics-science-and-engineering/
14. Mathematicians still checking the Navier-Stokes proof that OpenAI claims to have solved (The Tufts Daily, 2026-09-24) https://www.tuftsdaily.com/article/2026/09/mathematicians-still-checking-the-navier-stokes-proof-that-openai-claims-to-have-solved
15. OpenAI says its internal model solved over 100 long-standing math problems after just a month of training (The Decoder, 2026-09-22) https://the-decoder.com/openai-says-its-internal-model-solved-over-100-long-standing-math-problems-after-just-a-month-of-training/
16. AI agents do more of the work in model development, but humans still make the decisions (The Decoder, 2026-09-27) https://the-decoder.com/ai-agents-do-more-of-the-work-in-model-development-but-humans-still-make-the-decisions/
17. Vernor Vinge Lecture Series on the Future of AI and Society with Ted Chiang: No Machine Has Passed the Turing Test (TILOS, 2026) https://tilos.ai/event/vv-lecture-series-with-ted-chiang-no-machine-has-passed-the-turing-test/
18. Arrival Film Screening and Conversation (Epstein Family Amphitheater, 2026) https://amphitheater.ucsd.edu/event/arrival/
19. David Danks (UVA School of Data Science, 2026) https://datascience.virginia.edu/people/david-danks
20. Computing Machinery and Intelligence (Mind, 1950-10) https://www.hec.edu/sites/default/files/documents/Computing%20Machinery%20and%20Intelligence%20by%20Alan%20Turing.pdf
21. No, AI hasn't officially solved Navier–Stokes. Yet (Complexity Thoughts, 2026-09-10) https://manlius.substack.com/p/no-ai-hasnt-officially-solved-navierstokes

Method: https://si-infra.com/method · Ledger: https://si-infra.com/ledger · Founding paper: https://si-infra.com/whitepaper
